1916] OF THE SENATE. 1149

concur therein and have appointed on the part of the Sen-
ate Messrs. Shepherd, Duvall and Williams.

By order:

P. WATSON WEBB,

Secretary.

[Which was ready assented to, and sent to the House of
Delegates. ]

Mr. Bennett spoke on a point of personal privilege.

REPORTS OF STANDING COMMITTEES.

Mr. Cooper, from Committee on Finance, reported favor-
ably

HOUSE BILL No. 532, BY MR. LUTHARDT.
SUBJECT: DEPARTMENT OF LEGISLATIVE REFER-
ENCE.

[Which favorable report was adopted, which was read the
second time. ]

Two-thirds of all the Senators voting in the affirmative, the
rules were suspended by yeas and nays as follows, and Bill
put upon its third reading and final passage:

Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Brown Holmead Legg Warfield

Allen Chesley Johnson Mudd Williams

Archer Collier Jones Ogden Zihlman

Bennett Duvall Joy Parsons

Bomberger Harrison Kaufman Shepherd Total—23

Messrs. — NEGATIVE.

Frick Speicher Total—2

Which was read the third time and passed by yeas and nays
as follows:

Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Brown Holmead Legg Warfield

Allen Chesley Johnson Mudd Williams

Archer Collier Jones Ogden Zihlman

Bennett Duvall Joy Parsons

Bomberger Harrison Kaufman Shepherd Total—23

Messrs. — NEGATIVE.

Frick Speicher Total—2

[Said Bill was then returned to the House of Delegates. ]