1916] OF THE SENATE. 113

Mr. Frick voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Harrison voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Holmead voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Johnson voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Jones voted for Hon. John M. Dennis,

Mr. Joy voted for Hon. Robert F. Duer.

Mr. Kaufman voted for Hon. Robert F. Duer.

Mr. Legg voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Mudd voted for Hon. Robert F. Duer.

Mr. Norris voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Ogden voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Parsons voted for Hon. Robert F. Duer.

When the name of Mr. Shepherd was called, he announced
that he had paired with Mr. Zihlman, and he was excused
from voting, by request.

Mr. Speicher voted for Hon. Robert F. Duer.

Mr. Warfield voted for Hon. John M. Dennis.

Mr. Williams voted for Hon. Robert F. Duer.

Totals: Hon. John M. Dennis, 15; Hon. Robert F. Duer, 10.
[Which result was verified by the tellers. ]

The tellers then retired, with the ballot box, to count the
ballots conjointly with the tellers from the House of Dele-
gates.

At 4. 15 o'clock P. M., on motion of Mr. Holmead, the Senate
took a recess until 4. 30 o'clock P. M.

At 4. 30 o'clock P. M. the Senate resumed its session. Pres-
ent at roll call the following Senators:

Messrs. —

President Chesley Holmead Mudd Warfield

Allen Collier Johnson Norris Williams

Archer Cooper Jones Ogden

Bennett Duvall Joy Parsons

Bomberger Frick Kaufman Shepherd

Brown Harrison Legg Speicher —26

At 4. 35 o'clock P. M. the tellers returned and submitted the
following report:

8