clear space clear space clear space white space
A
 r c h i v e s   o f   M a r y l a n d   O n l i n e

PLEASE NOTE: The searchable text below was computer generated and may contain typographical errors. Numerical typos are particularly troubling. Click “View pdf” to see the original document.

  Maryland State Archives | Index | Help | Search
search for:
clear space
white space
Brantly's annotated Bland's Reports, Chancery Court 1809-1832
Volume 198, Volume 2, Page 248   View pdf image (33K)
 Jump to  
  << PREVIOUS  NEXT >>
clear space clear space clear space white space

248 CONTEE v. DAWSON.—2 BLAND.

264 *CONTEE v. DAWSON.

CHANCEEY PRACTICE.—ORDER TO BRING MONEY INTO COURT.—AGREEMENT
TO REFER TO ARBITRATION.—FORFEITURE OF LEGACY BY CONTESTING
WILL. — WHEN LEGACY WILL VEST.—LIABILITY OF TRUSTEES.—INVEST-
MENT OF LEGACIES.—EVIDENCE.

The plaintiff may set the case down for hearing on bill and answer; but, in

doing so, he admits the truth of every fact set forth in the answer.
Where an application is made, grounded on admissions in the answer, for

an order on the defendant to bring money into Court, the whole of his

answer must be taken together and for true, (a)
An order confirming an auditor's report is a judgment of this Court, final

in regard to the matter to which it relates. (6)
The foundation for an order to bring money into Court, must be found in

the direct progress of the case, and be such as is not open to be removed

or explained away.
No direction in a will, nor any mere agreement to refer a controversy to

arbitration can oust the proper Courts of justice of their jurisdiction in

the case, (c)

(a) See McKim v. Thompson, 1 Bland, 150.

(b) Approved in Pfeaff v. Jones, 50 Md. 269: Wayman v. Jones. 4 Md. Ch.
512.

(c) Approved in Trott v. Ins. Co. 1 Clifford. 443.

Agreements to refer to arbitration. Agreements in advance to oust the
Courts of the jurisdiction conferred by law are illegal and void. Ins. Co. v.
Morse, SO Wallace. 451; Allegre v. Ins. Co. 6 H. & J. 408. A Court of equity
will not, any more than a Court of law, enforce an agreement that in case
of dispute the matter shall be referred to arbitration, but it will leave the
parties to their own good pleasure in regard to such agreements. The regular
administration of justice might be greatly impeded or interfered with by
such stipulations, if they were specifically enforced. Story Eq. Jur. sec.
670. approved in Ins. Co. v. Morse, supra; Noyes v. Marsh, 123 Mass. 286.
A stipulation in a contract to submit any dispute concerning it to arbitra-
tion is no defence to an action at law. Wood v. Humphrey, 114 Mass. 185:
Pearl v. Harris, 121 Mass. 390. But such an agreement if only preliminary
to the action, such as respect the mode of settling the amount of damages,
or the time of paying it, will be sustained. Ibid.

" If two persons, whether in the same or a different deed from that which
creates the liability, agree to refer the matter upon which the liabilty arises
to arbitration, that agreement does not take away the right of action. But
if the original agreement is not simply to pay a sum of money, but that a
sum of money shall be paid if something else happens, and that something
else is that a third person shall settle the amount, then no cause of action
arises until the third person has so assessed the sum. For to say the con-
trary would be to give the party a different measure or rate of compensation
from that for which he has bargained.'' Elliott v. Assurance Co. L. R. 2 Ex.
237: Dawson v. Fitzgerald, 1 Ex. D. 257.

" Parties may, if they choose, make arbitration a condition precedent to
any right arising at all, and in that case the foregoing rules are inapplicable:

 

clear space
clear space
white space

Please view image to verify text. To report an error, please contact us.
Brantly's annotated Bland's Reports, Chancery Court 1809-1832
Volume 198, Volume 2, Page 248   View pdf image (33K)
 Jump to  
  << PREVIOUS  NEXT >>


This web site is presented for reference purposes under the doctrine of fair use. When this material is used, in whole or in part, proper citation and credit must be attributed to the Maryland State Archives. PLEASE NOTE: The site may contain material from other sources which may be under copyright. Rights assessment, and full originating source citation, is the responsibility of the user.


Tell Us What You Think About the Maryland State Archives Website!



An Archives of Maryland electronic publication.
For information contact mdlegal@mdarchives.state.md.us.

©Copyright  October 06, 2023
Maryland State Archives