1436 JOURNAL OF PROCEEDINGS [April 4,

The question then recurring upon the pasage of the bill,

It was rejected, for wantr of a constitutional majority, by
yeas and nays, as follows :

	AFFIRMATIVE.
Messrs.	Touchstone	Collins,
Latrobe, Speaker,	Marbury,	Gardner,
Martin,	Duvall,	Markland,
Beck,	Dennis,	Hobiitzell,
Wilmer,	Purnell,	Neill
Baldwin, of A. A., Mitchell,	McCreery, Harris,	Sword, Wilson, of Alle.,
Hammond,	Hardcastle, of Car.,	Jordan,
Hardcastle, of Tal.,	Wiley,	Winters,
Brattan,	McLane,	Merrick. — 31.
Harringtoa,	Kirk,
	NEGATIVE.
Messrs.	Owens,	Ehlen,
Kilbourn,	Ady,	Marshall,
Cameron,	Sanner,	Veitch,
Gatch,	Hamilton,	Watkins,
Choate,	Cooper,	Shower,
Lankford,	Blake,	Crawford— 17.

Said bill was then returned to the Senate.

The Secretary of the Senate delivered the following
message :

BY THE SENATE,
April 4th, 1870.

Gentlemen of the Souse of Delegates ; We respectfully ask your Honorable Body to return a bill

entitled an Act for the relief of B. F. May and others, for
further consideration by the Senate.

By order,

A. GASSAWAY,

Secretary.
Which was read.
Mr. Gorman submitted the following message :

BY THE HOUSE or DELEGATES,
April 4th, 1810.

Gentlemen of the Senate:

We have received your message asking the return to your