621

Mr. Crisfield, then moved to amend said substitute, by inserting
after the word "law" in the 9th line, the following:
"And in every case decided, an opinion in writing shall be filed,
and provision shall be made by law for publishing reports of cases
argued and determined in the said court;"
Detertnined in the affirmative.

Mr. Schley, moved further to amend said amendnent by adding
at the end thereof the following:
"And at the city of Frederick, for the hearing of appeals from
the counties of Allegany, Washington, Frederick, Carroll and
Montgomery, on the 1st Monday of May and September, in each
and every year;"
Mr. John Newcomer, moved the question be taken by yeas
and nays, and being ordered,appeared as follows
AFFIRMATIVE—Messrs. Hicks, George, Thomas, Gaither,
Biser, Sappington, Thawley, Schley, Fiery, John Newcomer,
Harbine, Michael Newcomer, Kilgour, Weber, Slicer, Fitzpatrick,
Smith, Parke, Shower and Cockey—20.

NEGATIVE—Messrs. Chapman, Pesr't, Morgan ,Blakistone, Dent,
Hopewell, Ricaud, Lee, Donaldson, Dorsey, Wells, Randall, Sell
man, Jenifer, Buchanan, Lloyd, Dickinson, James U. Dennis, Cris
field, Dashiell, W illiams, Hodson ,Goldsborough, Eccieston, Miller,
Bowie, Tuck, Sprigg, McCubbin, Spencer, Wright, Dirickson,
McMaster, Hearn, Fooks, Jacobs, Johnson, McHenry, Mcgraw,
Nelson, Gwinn, Stewart, of BaIt. city, Brent, of Balt. city, Sher
wood, of Balt. city, Ware, Davis, Brewer, Waters, Anderson and
Brown—49.

So the amendment was rejected.

Mr. Johnson, moved to amend said substitute by adding at the
end thereof, the following:

"And at such other times and places as the Legislature may by
law direct;"

Mr. Schley, moved the question be taken by yeas and nays, and
being ordered appeared as follows:

AFFIRMATIVE—Messrs. Buchanan, Spencer, George, Thomas,
Johnson, Gaither, user, Sappington, Nelson, Thawley, Gwinn,
Stewart of Balt, city, Sherwood of Balt, city, Ware, Schley,
Fiery, John Newcomer, Harbine, Michael Newcomer, Weber,
Slicer, Fitzpatrick, Parke and S hower—24.
NEGATIVE—Messrs. Chapman, Prest., Morgan, Blakistone,
Dent, Hopewell, Ricaud, Lee, Donaldson, Dorsey, Wells, Ran
dall, Sellman, Jenifer, Lloyd, Dickinson, James U. Dennis, Cris
field, Dashiell, Williams, Hicks, Hodson, Goldsborough, Eccies
ton, Miller, Bowie, Tuck, Sprigg, McCubbin, Wright, Dirickson,
McMaster, Heam, Fooks, Jacobs, McHenry, Magraw, Brent of