36 The Compact of 1785 the State, Virginia has passed no acts claiming such juris diction, while Maryland has passed such acts (Art. 27, sec. 631; Art. 75, sec. 161; 1939 Code). The Court of Appeals upheld the State's contention, saying that when the boundary disputes were finally set tled by the Award of 1877, "the reason for Virginia's having any criminal jurisdiction over the Potomac vanished, and with it went, by every intendment of common sense and legal reasoning, the jurisdiction itself." It noted further that under the statutes and decisions of Virginia, there is no longer any Virginia court with jurisdiction to try of fenses committed on the Potomac River, with the single exception of violations of the fishery laws. Hence, If Maryland courts cannot try such offenders as the appellant for acts committed within her boundaries, and if Virginia courts have no such authority, then the Potomac River becomes a highway for crime, a water-way within the State of Maryland where the criminals of Virginia, or those from elsewhere who commit offenses against the citizens of Virginia, can operate with immunity from punishment, and with complete freedom from all fear of consequences. Such a condition is unthinkable, and no court would be justified in holding it exists .... Elsewhere in the opinion there is the flat assertion that "concurrent jurisdiction is not yielded over any waters admitted to belong to Maryland by the tenth section" of the Compact. The decision of the Court was that Maryland had juris diction to try Barnes, and the conviction by the trial court was affirmed. The holding was that Virginia's jurisdiction over the Potomac River extends only to the fishing laws.' P. Summary of Judicial Decisions. The numerous cases which have construed the Compact have set down several propositions which are important in any evaluation of its present status. Briefly, they may be summarized as fol lows I Certiorari denied b3• the Supreme Court, 329 U. S. 754. |
||||
Tell Us What You Think About the Maryland State Archives Website!
|
An ecpCLIO electronic publication in the Archives of Maryland Series.
For information contact
edp@mdarchives.state.md.us.