Judicial History 35 cal jurisdiction over these shores, so that controversies over titles thereto would be justiciable only in Mary land and crimes committed thereon punishable only in Maryland courts. Accordingly, it was held, the Compact unquestionably set tled Maryland's jurisdiction and the rights of its citizens as extending only to the low water mark, and the Federal District Court in Virginia had jurisdictional authority to enjoin a trespass occurring between that line and the high water mark on the Virginia shore. O. Barnes v. Maryland (1946). The appellant Barnes was convicted in Prince George's County, Maryland, of committing a rape on a citizen of Virginia. The crime occurred on the Potomac River, on a boat en route from Norfolk to Washington. Claiming to be a citizen of Vir ginia, he disputed the jurisdiction of a Maryland court to try him, on the basis of Article 10 of the Compact. That Article had provided that in certain parts of the Chesapeake Bay, and in the Pocomoke and Potomac rivers, where the line of division between the two states was then doubtful, there should be a concurrent jurisdiction over "piracies, crimes or offenses;" and that an offense com mitted by a citizen of one state against a citizen of the other should be tried in the courts of the state of which the offender was a citizen. The Maryland Court of Appeals, in an opinion by Chief Judge Marbury, sustained the conviction, ruling that Mary land did have criminal jurisdiction over such offenses com mitted on the Potomac River. Included in the opinion is an interesting account of the origins and background of the Compact (Daily Record, May 17, 1946; 47 A. 2d 50; 186 Md. . .. . . ) . The State contended in the Barnes case that when the two states had accepted the Boundary Award of 1877, there was then no further uncertainty about the boundary along the Potomac River, and that the concurrent jurisdiction set up by Article 10 no longer prevailed. Further, said |
||||
Tell Us What You Think About the Maryland State Archives Website!
|
An ecpCLIO electronic publication in the Archives of Maryland Series.
For information contact
edp@mdarchives.state.md.us.