408 JOURNAL OF PROCEEDINGS [Mar. 6

Which was read the third time and passed by yeas and nays

as follows:

Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Chesley Harrison Kaufman Shepherd
Allen Collier Holmead Legg Speicher
Archer Cooper Johnson Mudd Warfield
Bomberger Duvall Jones Norris Williams
Brown Frick Joy Ogden Zihlman

Total—25
NEGATIVE—None.

[Said Bill was then sent to the House of Delegates. ]

Also

SENATE BILL No. 110, BY MR. ARCHER.

SUBJECT: REVENUE AND TAXES—EXEMPTIONS.

[Which was read and made the order of the day for March
8, 1916, at 1 o'clock P. M. ]

Also

SENATE JOINT RESOLUTION No. 14, BY MR. ZIHL-
MAN.

SUBJECT: APPOINTMENT OF COMMITTEE TO IN-
VESTIGATE STATE OFFICES.

Which was read the third time and passed by yeas and nays
as follows:
Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Collier Johnson Norris Williams

Allen Cooper Jones Ogden Zihlman

Archer Duvall Joy Parsons

Bomberger Frick Kaufman Shepherd

Brown Harrison Legg Speicher

Chesley Holmead Mudd Warfield Total—26

NEGATIVE—None.
[Said Resolution was then sent to the House of Delegates. ]

Also

SENATE BILL No. 13, BY MR. OGDEN.

SUBJECT: PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION.

Which was read and made the order of the day for March
13, 1916, at 8. 30 o'clock P. M., by yeas and nays as follows:
Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE,

Allen Brown Duvall Legg Zihlman

Archer Chesley Joy Parsons

Bomberger Collier Kaufman Williams Total—13

Messrs. — NEGATIVE.

President Frick Johnson Ogden Speicher
Cooper Holmead Norris Shepherd Warfield

Total—10