1310 JOURNAL OF PROCEEDINGS [Apr. 3

Mr. Zihlman moved to reconsider the vote. Which motion

prevailed by yeas and and nays as follows:

Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Bennett Joy Norris Williams
Allen Bomberger Kaufman Parsons Zihlman
Archer Brown Mudd Warfield Total—14

Messrs. — NEGATIVE.

Chesley Duvall, Holmead Jones Ogden
Collier Frick Johnson Legg Shepherd
Cooper Harrison Total—12

The Bill was again read the third time and failed for want
of a constitutional majority by yeas and nays as follows:
Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Bomberger Kaufman Parsons Williams
Archer Brown Mudd Warfield Zihlman
Bennett Joy Norris Total—13
Messrs. — NEGATIVE.

Chesley Duvall Holmead ' Jones Ogden
Collier Frick Johnson Legg Shepherd
Cooper Harrison Total—12

[Said Bill was then returned to the House of Delegates. ]
Also

HOUSE BILL No. 52, BY MR. FISHER.
SUBJECT: MINING LAWS—ALLEGANY AND GAR-
RETT COUNTIES.

Which was read the third time and failed for want of a
constitutional majority by yeas and nays as follows:
Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Joy Mudd Parsons Williams
Bomberger Kaufman Norris Warfield Zihlman
Brown Total—11
Messrs. — NEGATIVE.

Bennett Cooper Harrison Jones Ogden
Chesley Duvall Holmead Legg Shepherd
Collier Frick Johnson Total—-13

[Said Bill was then returned to the House of Delegates. ]

Two-thirds of all the Senators voting in the affirmative, the
rules were suspended by yeas and nays as follows:
Messrs. — AFFIRMATIVE.

President Chesley Holmead Mudd Warfield
Allen Collier Johnson Norris Williams
Archer Cooper Jones Ogden Zihlman
Bennett Duvall Joy Parsons
Bomberger Frick Kaufman Shepherd
Brown Harrison Legg Speicher Total—27
NEGATIVE—None.