Hall account of Webster case, 1850,
Image No: 27
   Enlarge and print image (50K)           << PREVIOUS  NEXT >>
clear space clear space clear space white space


 

Hall account of Webster case, 1850,
Image No: 27
   Enlarge and print image (50K)           << PREVIOUS  NEXT >>
27 clothes, and that they might not be seen, he confessed that he had hid them in the place where they were found; that it was true he had denied before the justice that he had changed his clothes, being con- nious that this was an ugly circumstance that might be urged against him, and being unwilling to be brought into trouble if he could help it; and concluded his story with a solemn declaration that he had re- lated nothing but the truth, without adding or diminishing one tittle, as he should answer it to God Almighty. Being then called on to produce his witnesses, the prisoner answered with a steady, composed countenance, and resolution of voice, "Ile had no witness but God and his own conscience." '° The judge then proceeded to deliver his charge, in which he pa- thetically enlarged on the heinousness of the crime, and laid great stress on the force of the evidence, which, although circunistantiad only, he declared he thought to be irresistible, and little inferior to the most posi- tive proof: that. the prisoner bad indeed cooked up a very plausible story, but if such, or the like allegations, were to be admitted, in a case of this kind, no murderer would ever be brought to justice, such bloody deeds being generally perpetrated in the dark, and with the greatest secrecy; that the present case was exempted, in his opinion, from all possibility of doubt, and that they ought not to hesitate one moment about finding the prisoner guilty. °' The foreman begged of his lordship, as this was a case of life and death, that the jury might be at liberty to withdraw, and upon this motion an officer was sworn to keep the jury. 1° The trial came on the first in the morning, and the judge having sat till nine at night, expecting the return of the, jury, at last sent an officer to inquire if they were agreed in their verdict, and to signify to them that his lordship would wait no longer for them. Some of them returned for answer that eleven of their body had been of the same mind from the first, but that it was their misfortune to have a foreman that proved to be a singular instance of the most inveterate obstinacy, who, having taken up a different opinion from them, was unalterably fixed in it. The messenger was no sooner returned, but the complaining members, alarmed at the thought of being kept under confinement all the night, and despairing of bringing their dissenting brother over to their own way of thinking, agreed to accede to his opinion, and having acquainted him with their resolution, they sent an officer to detain his worship a few minutes, and by their foreman brought in the prisoner not guilty. His lordship could not help ex- pressing the greatest surprise and indignation at this unexpected ver- dict; and after giving the jury a severe admonition, he refused to