1804 -1808 Thorowgood Smith
1808 -1816 Edward Johnson
1816 -1819 George Stiles
1819 -1820 Edward Johnson [Thomas Edward Cross]
1820 -1822 John Montgomery [Paula Foltz]
1822 -1824 Edward Johnson
1824 - 1826 John Montgomery
1826 - 1831 Jacob Small
1831 - 1832 William Steuart
1832 - 1835 Jesse Hunt
1835 - 1838 Samuel Smith [Keeve Nachman]
1838 - 1840 Sheppard C. Leakin
1840 - 1842 Samuel Brady [Joyce Schech]
1842 - 1843 Solomon Hillen, Jr.
1843 - 1844 James 0. Law
1844 - 1848 Jacob G. Davies
1848 - 1850 Elijah Stansbury [Katrina Henry]
1850 - 1852 John Hanson Thomas Jerome
1852 - 1854 John Smith Hollins [Brad Slinkman]
1854 - 1856 Samuel Hinks
1856 - 1860 Thomas Swann [Robert Little]
1860 - 1861 George William Brown [Noelia Cantu-Martin]
1861 - 1862 John C. Blackburn (Mayor ex-officio)
1862 - 1867 John Lee Chapman
1867 - 1871 Robert T. Banks
1871 -1875 Joshua Vansant
1875 - 1877 Ferdinand C. Latrobe
1877 - 1878 George P. Kane
1878 - 1881 Ferdinand C. Latrobe
1881 - 1883 William Pinkney Whyte
1883 - 1885 Ferdinand C. Latrobe [Dawn Rose]
1885 - 1887 James Hodges
1887 - 1889 Ferdinand C. Latrobe
1889 - 1891 Robert C. Davidson
1891 - 1895 Ferdinand C. Latrobe
1895 - 1897 Alcaeus Hooper
1897 - 1899 William T. Malster
1899 - 1903 Thomas G. Hayes
1903 - 1904 Robert M. McLane
