The Maryland Republican Party is proposing a redistricting
plan that would sharply cut Baltimore's representation in
Annapolis
- from 10 Senate districts to six - all contained strictly within city
lines and all with African-American majorities.
The Republicans are calling it an attempt to maximize minority representation.
Democrats are calling it "segregation."
The plan, which the GOP is preparing to
present to the governor's redistricting commission, contrasts sharply with
other proposals that seek to preserve the city's political power in the
face of significant population losses. There are now 10 state senators
whose districts lie wholly or partly in Baltimore.
The Republican plan stands no chance of adoption by Gov. Parris N. Glendening,
who must propose a plan on the opening day of the legislative session in
January, and by the Democratic-dominated General Assembly, which will have
45 days to approve that plan or substitute one of its own.
But GOP leaders, who expect Glendening to draw lines for maximum partisan
advantage, are threatening to challenge any Democratic-drawn plan in court
and to advance their proposed map as an alternative. "The courts will look
favorably upon it," said state Republican Party Chairman Michael Steele.
Herbert C. Smith, a political science professor at Western Maryland
College, said that normally the courts shy away from "the political thicket"
of redistricting. But he noted that Republican challenges to Democratic
redistricting plans have been successful in some Southern states and that
the success of the GOP plan could depend on which federal judge is assigned
to the case.
The final decision on Maryland's once-a-decade redistricting could be
made in the conservative 4th Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Va.,
or in the Supreme Court.
Democratic leaders are denouncing the Republican proposal as a plan
to disenfranchise African-Americans. "It is mean-spirited. It is divisive,
and it's a Republican Party dirty trick to pack minorities into as small
a population as possible," said Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller,
a Prince George's County Democrat.
Smith, a leading expert on Maryland politics, was no less harsh in his
judgment, calling the plan "political Balkanization" and "inappropriate."
State GOP leader Steele, an African-American from Prince George's County,
said the city's power would not be diminished if its lawmakers represent
their constituents effectively. "There are winners and losers in everything,"
he said.
"They've lost over 100,000 people in the city. You can't maintain the
same level of representation," he said. "It's unfair to those jurisdictions
that have gained in population."
Baltimore's population has declined by 84,860 - to 651,154 - between
the 1990 and 2000 censuses, continuing a slide that has been going on for
decades.
In the 1970s, Baltimore had 11 senators - all in districts within city
lines. In the 1980s, that number was reduced to nine.
After the 1990 census, Democratic leaders moved to preserve the city's
power in Annapolis
by reaching beyond jurisdictional boundaries and drawing five districts
that crossed into Baltimore County - bringing the number of districts with
some city residents up to 10.
That plan, which governed the 1994 and 1998 elections, has helped maintain
the diversity and political power of the Baltimore delegation. Baltimore
is represented by six African-American and four white senators - all Democrats.
They include such key players as Sen. Barbara A. Hoffman, chairman of
the powerful Budget and Taxation Committee; Majority Leader Clarence W.
Blount, who chairs the Education, Economic and Environmental Affairs Committee;
and Sen. Thomas L. Bromwell, chairman of the Finance Committee.
In contrast to the GOP redistricting plan, a plan being drafted by the
city's African-American senators would keep eight Senate seats representing
the city. Three districts would lie entirely within city lines, while five
others would straddle the city-county line.
The Republican plan would jeopardize the political careers of Baltimore's
two most powerful legislators, Hoffman and House Appropriations Committee
Chairman Howard P. Rawlings. Both lawmakers have used their positions to
protect the city's interests in state budget decisions.
Hoffman, who is white, would lose her county precincts and be forced
into a Senate district with a large African-American majority. Rawlings,
who is black, would be pushed into a single-member subdistrict with three
other delegates.
The plan would also put Bromwell's district entirely in the county,
and pit Sen. Perry Sfikas, who is white, against Sen. Nathaniel J. McFadden,
an African-American, in a black-majority 46th District. Sen. George W.
Della Jr., a white Democrat who represents southern Baltimore, would be
thrown into a redrawn 43rd District with black incumbents Blount, Ralph
M. Hughes and Clarence M. Mitchell IV.
Steele said a black majority district would not necessarily elect an
African-American legislator. "Black folks will elect white folks," he said.
"Black folks will elect people who represent their interests."
The plan would also cut the number of delegates with all or part of
their districts in the city from 29 to 18. All would be elected from single-member
subdistricts - three of which would have white majorities.
The city's current House delegation is made up of 16 African-Americans
and 13 whites.
The 2000 census put Baltimore's population at 64 percent black and 31
percent white. Under the GOP plan, none of the city's Senate districts
and 17 percent of House subdistricts would have white majorities.
The Republican plan and the Democrats' stated intentions show a basic
disagreement on the political relationship of the city and Baltimore County.
To Steele, the two jurisdictions should have separate representation
because "urban needs are very different from suburban needs."
"Baltimore County is not Baltimore City," he said. "I don't think it
works in the best interests of the people in the city to have their interests
diluted."
But Miller, a member of the redistricting commission, defended the state's
decision to draw city-county districts a decade ago. "It was about saving
and enhancing an urban center," he said.
Baltimore County Executive C.A. Dutch Ruppersberger, a Democrat, said
he opposed the idea of shared districts when they were proposed but has
changed his mind. "It allowed us to form a large bloc of votes that helped
to improve our ability to receive state money that we weren't getting in
the past," he said.
Del. Talmadge Branch, a Baltimore Democrat who heads the Legislative
Black Caucus, said it is not in the city's best interests to send a nearly
all-black delegation to Annapolis.
"We should not have a total black city," he said. "We need to have a cross-section
of whites representing the city."