Bemis Report of the Webster Trial, 1850 [1897], Image No: 226   Enlarge and print image (70K)           << PREVIOUS  NEXT >>
clear space clear space clear space white space


 

Bemis Report of the Webster Trial, 1850 [1897], Image No: 226   Enlarge and print image (70K)           << PREVIOUS  NEXT >>
226 TRIAL OF JOHN W. WEBSTER. injury in that place upon the person of Dr. Parkman. If such were thus truly his ponvictions,-if his whole statement upon this subject is not a gross misrepresentation, could he have been so careless and indifferent as utterly to have neglected this early and favorable opportunity to look around, and satisfy himself if any traces of violence or indications of its occurrence were to be found there? Would not his eye have fallen upon every object in natural and instinctive search of some token of guilt? Would his vision have been closed when he was in the midst of scenes where, if at all, must have been perpetrated that terrible crime of which his mind was filled with grievous and irrepressible suspicions? But, though he knew that Dr. Webster was then detained in conversa- tion, and would not therefore interrupt any examination he might make, he returned to his own apartments in listless inattention, as if nothing had occurred to excite his apprehensions! He who had been so vigilant before in watching the bolted doors, now that they are open, and all is exposed to his inspection, does not pause to make a single observation! During the same morning, Mr. Parkman Blake came there; and, to gain admission for him, Littlefield passes once more alone through the laboratory, but took no advantage of this second entrance to make him- self acquainted with the condition of things within it. At a still later hour during the same forenoon, Mr. Kingsley, the agent, and Mr. Stark- weather, the police-officer, called there to make search in the College for Dr. Parkman; and they applied to Littlefield to assist them in gaining admission. It was many hours before this, as he tells you, that his mind was filled with the ineradicable conviction that Dr. Webster was guilty of murder. If such was indeed the state of his mind, how would he now have acted or been disposed to act when accompanied by officers of the police, armed with the authority of law, and charged with the duty of investigation? Would he not have seized eagerly upon that oppor- tunity for the most thorough search? Would he not have watched every indication? Would not his suspicions have induced him to point the attention of the police to every source and quarter of inquiry? Yet he owns to you that both he and they made but a mere formal passage through the apartments, and that nothing like a search was either attempted or proposed. You may follow him still further in his progress, but it will be the same result. Before his suspicions were excited, he was full of watch- fulness;-when his convictions were most firm, he subsided into indif- ference. Tuesday carne round, and a still larger force of the police came to the College. None of his former convictions were eradicated from his mind, nor were they in any degree diminished or weakened. He accom- panied the officers, and heard Mr. Clapp say to Dr. Webster, " We do not suspect you at all; but we are ordered to search all this part of the city; and the neighbors may object to a search upon their premises. unless one is first made here." Yet, hearing this strong exculpatory apology of the police, Littlefield, who professes to have believed in his heart that Dr. Webster was a murderer, would not even suggest a hint to the officers that it might be worth while to be a little more vigilant! And when the party had got into the laboratory, and when that sig- nificant inquiry, mentioned by some of the witnesses, was made about the privy, and Dr. Webster so adroitly withdrew their attention from it, even then Mr. Littlefield could not be roused to the suggestion of the expediency of a more exact examination. Nay; he was the least observ- ant of all who were present. Kingsley made discovery of the spots of nitrate of copper on the stairs, and of the fire in the assay-furnace; but so careless was his observation, that they wholly escaped the notice of Littlefield. In the nature of things, can it be that such weighty suspicions should have rested upon his mind,-suspicions which could not but have prompted to the most anxious and vigilant observation,-and that he